John Locke wrote Two Treatises of Government, published anonymously in December 1689. The answer is option (d). The other three names attached to this question — Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Baron de Montesquieu, and Thomas Hobbes — each wrote foundational political works, but none of them wrote the Two Treatises. The full title on the first printing was Two Treatises of Government: In the Former, The False Principles and Foundation of Sir Robert Filmer, and His Followers, Are Detected and Overthrown. The Latter Is an Essay Concerning the True Original, Extent, and End of Civil-Government — a mouthful that explains why almost nobody today uses the complete name.
Locke's authorship matters because the Second Treatise supplied the intellectual scaffolding for the American Declaration of Independence, the U.S. Constitution's separation-of-powers logic, and the modern language of natural rights. Thomas Jefferson's rough draft of the Declaration echoes Locke's triad of "life, liberty, and estate" (Locke's phrase) recast as "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness." Anyone studying the Enlightenment, preparing for an AP European History exam, or writing about the origins of liberal democracy needs to know the attribution cold. The confusion usually comes from a reading list that bundles Locke, Hobbes, Rousseau, and Montesquieu together as "social contract thinkers," which is accurate as a category label but useless as an identification tool.
The Two Treatises Was Published Anonymously for a Reason
Locke didn't attach his name to the first edition, and that fact alone trips up students who skim bibliographies. The book appeared in December 1689 with a 1690 date on the title page — a common publishing practice of the era that led many library catalogs to list the Two Treatises as a 1690 publication. Modern scholars generally cite December 1689 for the physical release. The Whig historian Peter Laslett, whose 1960 Cambridge edition is still the standard scholarly text, demonstrated the composition timeline through close analysis of Locke's manuscripts and the papers of his circle.
The anonymity was practical self-protection. Locke had returned to England in February 1689 aboard the same ship as Mary II, after five years of exile in the Netherlands following the Rye House Plot. The Two Treatises attacks absolute monarchy in terms that would have read as sedition before the Glorious Revolution settled matters. By publishing without a name, Locke could let the argument circulate while keeping a screening distance from prosecution. His authorship became widely known in his own lifetime, and it was never seriously in doubt once his library and correspondence were examined.
Understanding the timing matters for exam questions. The First Treatise — the dense, nearly unreadable demolition of Sir Robert Filmer's Patriarcha — was likely drafted around 1680, well before the Revolution. The Second Treatise, the book everyone actually reads, was probably composed between 1681 and 1683, refined during exile, and lightly updated for publication. The ideas weren't a post-revolutionary rationalization; they were the argument Locke had been building while the Exclusion Crisis raged.
The book has never gone out of print in any meaningful sense. Cambridge University Press has issued Laslett's edition continuously since 1960, and Penguin Classics and Hackett Publishing both maintain teaching editions. That availability is one reason the Two Treatises anchors so many syllabi: it's cheap, short in its essential second half, and endlessly quotable.
What the Second Treatise Actually Argues in Five Chapters
If you've never read past the title, here's the argument structure in the order the Second Treatise builds it. Locke starts in Chapter II with the state of nature: a condition of perfect freedom and equality governed by a law of nature that obliges no one to harm another's life, health, liberty, or possessions. Crucially, Locke's state of nature is not Hobbes's war of all against all — it's a tolerable condition with inconveniences, chiefly the absence of an impartial judge.
Chapter V, "Of Property," is the most-cited and least-understood section. Locke grounds property in labor: mixing your work with the raw material of the earth makes it yours. That argument has been read as a defense of enclosure, a proto-labor theory of value, and everything in between. Then, in Chapter VIII, he makes the pivot that defines the book — consent. "Men being, as has been said, by nature all free, equal, and independent, no one can be put out of this estate and subjected to the political power of another without his own consent." Political authority is constructed, not divinely inherited, which is exactly the opposite of Filmer's claim.
Chapters IX through XIX work out the mechanics. The great end of civil society is the preservation of property — and Locke's "property" stretches to mean life, liberty, and estate together. Government holds power in trust. When a legislature breaches that trust, or an executive seizes the legislative power, the people retain a right to alter or abolish the government. Chapter XIX, "Of the Dissolution of Government," lays out the conditions that trigger that right.
The famous "appeal to heaven" phrase in Chapter XIX is Locke's answer to the objection that his theory licenses chaos: when there is no earthly judge between ruler and people, the people appeal to God. That phrase later became a slogan of the American revolutionaries and appears in the preamble language of colonial protest documents.
| Lockean Claim | Chapter | What It Actually Says | Common Misreading |
|---|---|---|---|
| State of nature | II | Free and equal under natural law, but inconvenient | That Locke thought life was brutally violent |
| Property | V | Labor mixes with materials to create ownership | That Locke had no limits on accumulation |
| Consent | VIII | Political authority arises only from agreement | That Locke required explicit, formal voting |
| Prerogative | XIV | Executive may act beyond written law for public good | That Locke endorsed unlimited royal power |
| Dissolution | XIX | People may alter government when trust is breached | That Locke advocated routine revolution |
Locke's word count gives a clue to his priorities. The First Treatise runs roughly 900 pages of printed text in some modern editions and is a polemic against one dead royalist thinker. The Second Treatise is about 400 pages in the same format and is the text that matters. If a syllabus assigns the Two Treatises and then only discusses the Second, that's normal — instructors rarely spend more than a week on the First.
Why Rousseau, Hobbes, and Montesquieu Get Confused With Locke
The multiple-choice trap on this question is that all four men fit the same intellectual category, so a test-taker under time pressure has to map each name to a specific title. That's a memory problem with a simple fix: attach one distinctive book to each thinker and you'll never miss it again.
| Thinker | Answer Option | Famous Work | Date | Core Idea | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jean-Jacques Rousseau | (a) | The Social Contract | 1762 | General will; sovereignty held by the people collectively | |
| Baron de Montesquieu | (b) | The Spirit of the Laws | 1748 | Separation of powers; laws shaped by climate, custom, and geography | |
| Thomas Hobbes | (c) | Leviathan | 1651 | Absolute sovereign needed to escape the war of all against all | |
| John Locke | (d) | Two Treatises of Government | 1689 | Natural rights; government by consent, held in trust |
Hobbes is the easiest to confuse with Locke because both use the phrase "state of nature." Hobbes wrote of a condition of "continual fear, and danger of violent death" where life is "solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short" — a line from Chapter XIII of Leviathan. Locke read Hobbes and rejected the conclusion that only an all-powerful sovereign could fix the problem. That contrast makes a strong exam answer, but for identification purposes, Leviathan is Hobbes and the Two Treatises is Locke.
Rousseau did write about the social contract, which explains a lot of the confusion. On the Social Contract appeared in 1762, seventy-three years after Locke's work, and argued for popular sovereignty expressed through the general will. The title "The Social Contract" shares the concept of contract with Locke but not the book title. Montesquieu's The Spirit of the Laws was published in 1748 and influenced the American founders' design of separate branches — James Madison cites Montesquieu repeatedly in the Federalist Papers. None of these three wrote the book the question asks about.
If you want to check an edition yourself, the first printing's title page reads Two Treatises of Government and credits no author at all. Confirm through the Cambridge edition edited by Laslett, which includes the full bibliographic history, or through the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy's Locke bibliography.
The Glorious Revolution Context You Need for Exam Questions
Teachers love asking not just who wrote the Two Treatises but why it appeared when it did. The safest answer ties it to the Glorious Revolution of 1688–89. James II fled England in December 1688, William and Mary took the throne in early 1689, and Locke's book arrived months later alongside the new settlement. That sequence is easy to remember and hard to argue with.
The complication is that Laslett's manuscript research showed most of the Second Treatise predates the Revolution by several years. Locke had been writing against absolute monarchy during the Exclusion Crisis (1678–1681), when Parliament tried to prevent James, Duke of York, a Catholic, from inheriting the throne. That means the book is not a retrospective justification of the Revolution so much as a theory that had been waiting for its moment. An exam answer that says "the Two Treatises was published in 1689, in the wake of the Glorious Revolution, but drafted much earlier in the context of the Exclusion Crisis" is the version most likely to survive a grader's scrutiny.
Locke's financial stake in the Revolution is also worth knowing. He held positions in the English administration after 1689, including a role on the Board of Trade in 1696, which made the theory of government by consent a matter of personal career as well as conviction. That connection isn't a knock on the argument; it's the reason the argument was taken seriously in Whig circles.
For AP European History, the multiple-choice version of this question is likely to appear alongside Hobbes, Rousseau, and Montesquieu as distractors. The exam's course framework lists "the Second Treatise of Government" as the key Locke text, and its thematic category is intellectual and cultural developments in the 17th and 18th centuries. Answering quickly on identification requires the four-book mapping above, not a deep reading of the text.
Two Treatises vs Leviathan: The Comparison That Explains the Liberal Tradition
The most useful comparison for readers trying to understand the Enlightenment political tradition is Locke against Hobbes on the same dimensions. It's also the comparison that answers the confusion in the keyword most cleanly, because the Two Treatises was written in part as an argument against the conclusions Hobbes had reached.
| Dimension | Locke, Two Treatises (1689) | Hobbes, Leviathan (1651) |
|---|---|---|
| State of nature | Free and equal; inconvenienced but not lethal | War of all against all; life "brutish and short" |
| Purpose of government | Preserve natural rights and property | Escape fear and prevent civil war |
| Sovereign power | Limited, held in trust, revocable | Absolute, indivisible, near-permanent |
| Right of resistance | Ensured when government breaches trust | Denied; resistance is unjust |
| Religion | Tolerant of dissent in most matters | Sovereign controls public worship |
| Consent | Explicit or tacit agreement to be governed | Covenant to authorize a sovereign unconditionally |
| Influence on America | Declaration of Independence; Constitution | Realist strands in Federalist debates, but limited |
Reading the two side by side shows students why Locke's Second Treatise became the operative theory in the Anglo-American world. Hobbes offered a theory that justified nearly any strong ruler; Locke offered one that could be claimed by revolutionaries and constitutionalists alike. That versatility is why the Two Treatises sits at the root of the liberal political tradition.
One reading note: Locke's A Letter Concerning Toleration, published in Latin in 1689 and in English in 1689–1690, pairs naturally with the Two Treatises in courses because it argues for freedom of religious conscience limited by public order. It's a short tract — under 100 pages in most editions — and it's a better use of a week than the First Treatise.
How Locke's Second Treatise Shows Up in American Founding Documents
Jefferson didn't cite Locke by name in the Declaration of Independence, but the structural borrowing is hard to miss once you know what to look for. Locke's "life, liberty, and estate" becomes "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness." His "unalienable" natural rights, derived from the state of nature, appear in the Declaration's sentence about rights that are "endowed by their Creator." And the Declaration's claim that governments derive "their just powers from the consent of the governed" is a compressed paraphrase of Locke's Chapter VIII argument.
The American founders also cited the Two Treatises indirectly through their reading habits. Historian Donald Lutz's surveys of American political writing during the founding era, conducted with co-author Charles Hyneman, placed Locke among the most frequently cited secular sources in the period's pamphlet and newspaper literature. The precise ranking varies by year and by which corpus is counted, so treat any specific position with care — but the volume is not in dispute.
The Constitutional Convention added the separation of powers, and Locke's Two Treatises doesn't prescribe that structure in detail. That part of the American design owed more to Montesquieu, whose Spirit of the Laws repeatedly cites the English constitution as a model of separated powers. So a careful answer for an essay question is: Two Treatises supplied rights and consent language; Spirit of the Laws supplied separation-of-powers mechanics.
Where the founders and Locke diverged is instructive. Locke assumed a "promise-keeping" executive who would act for the public good, and his theory of prerogative assumed reasonably virtuous rulers. The Constitution's checks and balances, and the Federalist Papers' insistence on "auxiliary precautions," showed less faith in rulers than Locke had. That divergence is useful for anyone writing about the American founding in a paper or exam answer.
Five Fact-Check Errors That Cause Wrong Answers
The keyword question is a multiple-choice item, and most wrong answers come from a small set of predictable errors. Here's the checklist. Run through it before a test, and none of these mistakes will misfire.
1: Attaching "The Social Contract" to Locke. Rousseau wrote it in 1762. Locke wrote Two Treatises in 1689. The concept of a social contract appears in both, but only Rousseau titled a book after it. 2: Mixing up Hobbes and Locke on the state of nature. Both use the phrase, but Hobbes is the one with the war of all against all. Locke's condition of natural liberty is free, equal, and inconvenient — not violent by default. 3: Assuming anonymous means unknown. The Two Treatises was anonymous in 1689; authorship was established in Locke's lifetime. Check the Cambridge edition or any standard bibliography to confirm attribution. 4: Confusing title-page dates with publication dates. The December 1689 edition carries a 1690 imprint. Modern sources list it under 1689 based on printing records — check the publisher's notes for the exact source you are using. 5: Bundling "social contract thinkers" and picking any name. The category includes all four men; the identification requires the specific title. Match book title to author before you match concept to author.
Failure in the exam-grade case rarely looks like not knowing the book. It usually looks like knowing that Locke was a social contract thinker and then panicking because Hobbes and Rousseau were on the list. The fix is the book-author map, not a longer essay on contract theory.
For anyone writing a paper, the same errors appear in print as false attributions. A quick check against the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy entry on Locke, the Cambridge edition's front matter, and the British Library catalogue will settle the attribution in under five minutes.
Reading the Two Treatises as a Student: Edition, Word Count, and Price
The two editions that dominate classroom use carry very different price points and formats. The Cambridge edition, edited by Laslett, includes a long scholarly introduction that runs over 100 pages — useful for research, heavy for a first read. Penguin and Hackett editions pack the Second Treatise with a short introduction and range between roughly 200 and 400 pages depending on which texts are included. Confirm current pricing and page counts on the publishers' own product pages, since prices vary by region and by year.
A shorter path for beginners is to read only the Second Treatise, Chapters II, V, VIII, IX, and XIX. That selection runs roughly 100 pages in a modern annotated edition and gives you the state of nature, property, consent, the ends of government, and the right of resistance. Read the First Treatise later, if at all.
If you plan to quote Locke in a paper, keep an eye on the spelling of "civil-government" as printed on the original title page, and consult the Cambridge edition's note on how to cite. Some editions modernize punctuation and capitalization, which affects quotation accuracy. Confirm the edition you quote from before submitting.
Word counts of the Two Treatises full text vary substantially by edition and by whether the First Treatise is included. For exam purposes, the important facts are that the First dwarfs the Second in length and that only the Second supplies the modern political theory curriculum.
FAQ
Is it true that Hobbes wrote the Two Treatises?
No. Thomas Hobbes wrote Leviathan (1651). The Two Treatises is Locke's, published in December 1689. The confusion arises because both write about the state of nature, but their conclusions about the sovereign differ sharply. Check any standard bibliography — Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy lists the Two Treatises under Locke's works.
Did Locke write Two Treatises before the Glorious Revolution?
Yes — the manuscript evidence shows the Second Treatise was largely drafted between 1681 and 1683, during the Exclusion Crisis. It was published in 1689 after the Revolution created the conditions for it to circulate safely. Cambridge editor Peter Laslett's dating is the standard used in scholarship.
What is the difference between the First and Second Treatise?
The First Treatise is a point-by-point attack on Sir Robert Filmer's Patriarcha, which defended the divine right of kings. The Second Treatise builds Locke's own constructive theory of natural rights, consent, and limited government. Modern readers almost always read only the Second — the First runs roughly twice as long and is largely obsolete as a philosophical work.
Was Two Treatises anonymous when first published?
Yes. The December 1689 edition carried no author's name on the title page. Locke's authorship was known to his circle and was publicly established within his lifetime, partly because he acknowledged the work himself and his papers made the connection clear. Ownership records in the Stationers' Company belong to the publisher, not the author.
Which Enlightenment thinker influenced the US Constitution most?
Locke influenced the Declaration's language of unalienable rights and consent; Montesquieu influenced the separation-of-powers structure. No founder cites the Two Treatises in the Federalist Papers directly, but Locke's argument is widely recognized as foundational to the political theory the Constitution assumes.
Is Rousseau's "The Social Contract" the same book as Locke's "Two Treatises on Government"?
No. They are different books, published 73 years apart — Locke's in 1689, Rousseau's in 1762. Both discuss the social contract, but Locke's emphasis is on natural rights and limited government, while Rousseau's is on the general will and popular sovereignty. If a question names "Two Treatises on Government," the answer is Locke.
Did Locke write anything else about government?
Yes. A Letter Concerning Toleration (1689) argues for religious toleration within limits, and Some Thoughts Concerning Education (1693) discusses how citizens should be raised — much of his educational theory presupposes the political philosophy of the Two Treatises. Both are useful companions in a political theory course.
What if I see the Two Treatises dated 1690 on a library catalog?
Many catalogs list 1690 because the first printing carried a 1690 imprint date even though the physical release was December 1689. Either date can appear in a syllabus; for exam purposes, say 1689 for the published work and note the 1690 imprint if the question probes the date. Confirm the publication record through the Cambridge edition's front matter or the British Library catalogue.
This article is general educational information about the history of political thought, not legal advice. If you are working on a graded assignment, consult your instructor's required edition and citation format before submitting.