A mistrial is a trial a judge ends before a verdict because a fundamental unfairness or deadlock means the proceeding can't reach a valid result. The case isn't dismissed — it's erased and, in most instances, can be retried from jury selection onward. The controlling legal standard is "manifest necessity," a phrase the U.S. Supreme Court adopted from Justice Story's 1824 opinion in United States v. Perez, and it governs whether prosecutors get a second attempt or lose the case permanently.
That distinction matters more than most explanations admit. Whether a mistrial helps or destroys a case depends almost entirely on who asked for it and why, and the gap between a "manifest necessity" mistrial and a "prosecutorial overreach" mistrial can be the difference between a retrial and a dismissal with prejudice. This article walks through the mechanics, the triggers, the costs, and the double-jeopardy math that determines what happens next.
Manifest Necessity: The Legal Test a Judge Actually Applies
Judges don't declare mistrials on a hunch; they apply a two-part test built from Perez and refined in Arizona v. Washington (1978). First, the judge finds a "manifest necessity" — a circumstance so serious that continuing would be unfair or impossible. Second, the judge weighs that necessity against the defendant's "valued right to have his trial completed by a particular tribunal," language from Wade v. Hunter (1949). The heavier the prejudice to the defense, the more the judge scrutinizes the government's conduct.
The standard is deliberately flexible because the Supreme Court refused to lock it into a checklist. In Arizona v. Washington, the Court reasoned that a rigid rule would impair a judge's ability to respond to unanticipated problems. In practice, appellate courts defer heavily to the trial judge unless the record shows the judge acted "irrationally or irresponsibly" — the standard set in United States v. Jorn (1971). That deference is why mistrial rulings rarely get overturned on appeal.
A practical consequence: the judge must usually state the reasoning on the record. If the judge declares a mistrial without articulating why, defense counsel can argue on appeal that the record fails to show manifest necessity. Defense attorneys routinely object on the record and ask for a specific finding; prosecutors often request a continuance to brief the issue rather than let a rushed ruling stand.
The retreat to chambers is the moment most people picture from courtroom dramas, but the actual work looks different. The judge calls counsel to sidebar or a conference room, hears arguments from both sides, sometimes questions a juror individually under oath, and then returns to the bench to rule. The jury is usually instructed not to discuss the case, and the judge has a duty to explore less drastic alternatives — a curative instruction, removing one juror with an alternate, a brief continuance — before pulling the plug.
Seven Triggers That Actually Produce a Mistrial
Deadlocked juries account for the largest share of mistrials in criminal courts, but they're far from the only path. The trigger determines everything about what happens next, so it's worth separating them by who caused the problem.
| Trigger | Typical Requesting Party | Result on Jeopardy | Retrial Likely? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hung jury | Judge (sua sponte) | Does not attach | Yes, strong |
| Deadlocked jury (civil) | Judge | Depends on jurisdiction's rule | Often, if plaintiff persists |
| Juror misconduct (outside research, contact) | Either party | Varies by prejudice found | Usually yes |
| Improper attorney statement | Opposing counsel | Varies by severity | Often, but prejudiced party may seek dismissal |
| Judicial bias or error | Either party | Varies | Depends on severity |
| Unavailable juror or witness | Either party | Usually no | Yes |
| Prosecutorial overreach | Defense | Attaches if intentional | No, if bad faith found |
Each row hides a volume of case law. Juror misconduct, for example, splits into two very different categories: conduct inside the jury room (discussing the case early, considering facts not in evidence) and conduct outside it (independent research, contacting witnesses, social media posts). The first usually draws a curative instruction; the second, especially internet research, increasingly draws a mistrial because the contaminated juror's influence can't be contained.
Defense-initiated mistrials carry a hidden risk. When the defense requests the mistrial, the double jeopardy bar generally does not attach unless the prosecution deliberately provoked the request — the standard from Oregon v. Kennedy (1982), which requires "intent to cause a mistrial" or "harassment" of the defendant. That's a high bar, and many defense attorneys hesitate to request mistrials mid-trial for exactly this reason: a second trial means a second chance for a conviction.
Hung Juries: The Most Common Mistrial and the Numbers Behind It
When a jury reports it cannot reach a verdict, the judge faces a choice: give an Allen charge (also called a dynamite charge) telling jurors to try again, or accept the deadlock and declare a mistrial. The Allen charge comes from Allen v. United States (1896), and it remains controversial because it can pressure holdout jurors. Most judges give it once, sometimes twice, before declaring a mistrial.
Deadlock itself doesn't end the case. In a criminal case, the prosecution decides whether to retry — and many do, because a hung jury produces no acquittal and no bar to a second trial. Where a retrial happens, the numbers don't favor the defense: the U.S. Department of Justice's Bureau of Justice Statistics found in its Felony Defendants in Large Urban Counties reports that a substantial share of hung-jury cases that go to retrial end in conviction, though exact figures vary by jurisdiction and charge. (Which jurisdiction and charge matter enormously — murder retrials differ sharply from misdemeanor retrials.)
The time cost is the part defendants feel most. A retrial typically means a new jury pool, a new voir dire, and re-presentation of evidence, which commonly runs three to nine months after the mistrial in state felony courts. Defense counsel who has already prepared once discounts the second preparation, but the emotional and financial toll for the defendant compounds, and witnesses who appeared once are often less cooperative the second time.
A hung jury is not the only verdict failure. A judge can also declare a mistrial when the jury returns an inconsistent verdict — convicting on one count and acquitting on another in a way that defies logic — though this is rare and appellate courts often resolve it through other means. The deadlocked-jury mistrial remains the workhorse, and the Allen charge is the judge's main tool for avoiding it.
The One Mistrial That Ends the Case: Bad-Faith Prosecutorial Conduct
Most mistrials reset the calendar. A mistrial granted because the prosecution deliberately provoked a defense request, or because the prosecution committed an error so prejudicial that no instruction could cure it, can bar retrial entirely under the Double Jeopardy Clause. Oregon v. Kennedy set the standard: the prosecution must have intended to "goad" the defendant into requesting a mistrial, or acted to "harass" the defense. Intent is inferred from the record, not admitted.
The line between ordinary error and misconduct is the fight that consumes most mistrial appeals. In United States v. Jorn (1971), the Supreme Court held the prosecution could not retry a defendant after the judge dismissed the jury to give the prosecution's witnesses time to consult counsel — the judge's ruling was an abuse of discretion, and jeopardy attached. In Illinois v. Somerville (1973), by contrast, a mistrial declared because the indictment was defective allowed retrial, since the defect would have forced a reversal on appeal anyway. The contrast shows how much weight attaches to why the judge acted.
Prosecutorial misconduct as a category includes inflammatory closing arguments, introducing evidence the judge had already excluded, and failing to turn over Brady material. Most such cases don't even reach a mistrial — the judge issues a curative instruction and the trial continues, and defendants preserve the issue for appeal. The mistrial decision is a last resort when the judge believes the bell cannot be unrung.
For defendants, the value of a bad-faith finding is enormous and the scarcity is real. A successful Kennedy showing means the case is over, not deferred. For prosecutors, the cost is a reputational and supervisory one — many district attorney offices have internal review processes that trigger when a mistrial is granted for prosecutorial error, which is why some offices require supervisory approval before closing argument language that risks a mistrial.
When Juror Misconduct Poisons the Panel
The internet broke the old rules for jury conduct. Jurors now carry research tools in their pockets, and trial judges routinely instruct them not to search for defendants' names, not to read news coverage, and not to post about the trial. When a juror violates those instructions, the judge must investigate: question the juror, sometimes the whole panel, and decide whether the contamination spreads.
The key question is prejudice. If the juror consulted a definition of a legal term, the court may find the error harmless. If the juror looked up the defendant's criminal history or the alleged victim's family, or read a news story summarizing evidence the judge excluded, the presumption of prejudice becomes hard to overcome. Courts have declared mistrials over social media posts by jurors that revealed a verdict preference before deliberations, because the premature leaning can taint discussions.
The investigation itself can create a problem. Questioning jurors about deliberations risks intruding into jury secrecy, protected under Federal Rule of Evidence 606(b) (in federal courts) and comparable state rules. The judge must stay focused on external influences, not the jurors' mental processes — a distinction that sounds clean in theory but gets fuzzy when the alleged misconduct is something a juror said during deliberations.
Judges increasingly attach consequences to the offending juror as well. Courts can hold a juror in contempt for violating instructions, and a few states have added specific jury-tampering provisions for internet research. For lawyers, the practical lesson is that juror questionnaires and expanded voir dire on internet habits have become standard in high-profile trials, because catching a research-prone juror before deliberations is far cheaper than a mistrial later.
Who Pulls the Trigger: Judge, Defense, or Prosecution
The mechanics of declaring a mistrial differ depending on who initiates it, and each has a distinct strategic flavor. Understanding who moves first helps explain why courtroom strategy so often revolves around the mistrial decision.
The judge acts sua sponte when no party requests it. Judges hesitate to act unilaterally, because a defense appeal will scrutinize whether the judge considered alternatives. The safe practice is a hearing on the record, an evaluation of less drastic remedies, and an explicit finding of manifest necessity.
The defense requests a mistrial when the prosecution's error is so severe that continuing risks conviction. The risk: double jeopardy doesn't attach unless Kennedy bad faith is shown, so the defense may trade a potentially reversible conviction for a clean second trial. Good defense attorneys weigh whether the error is appealable post-conviction instead.
The prosecution requests a mistrial when it discovers a problem it can't fix — a missing witness, a discovery violation by the prosecution itself that the defense will exploit, or juror misconduct that favors the defense. Prosecutors rarely want a mistrial because the defense gets another voir dire and the state pays to try the case twice.
A fourth route exists: the parties can stipulate to a mistrial. When both sides agree that a problem is unfixable, they can ask the judge to declare one jointly, which streamlines the process and reduces appeal risk. Stipulated mistrials are common in complex civil cases where a discovery dispute or a settlement conversation surfaces mid-trial.
The Financial and Calendar Cost of Starting Over
A mistrial is expensive on both sides. A civil trial that runs six days and ends in a mistrial at least doubles the trial cost, and the pretrial preparation — depositions, expert reports, motions in limine — usually has to be refreshed because memories fade and experts may need new updates. For a complex commercial case, legal fees through trial commonly run into six figures per side, so a mistrial roughly doubles the trial-phase outlay.
Criminal costs fall mainly on the state. The government must pay for a second jury pool, court reporter time, and prosecution hours, and public defenders in most jurisdictions are paid regardless. Court administrators in several states have studied the cost of retrials and consistently find the mistrial retrial burden is one of the largest hidden costs in the criminal calendar.
The calendar cost is the one defendants feel. Many courts set a retrial date within 70 days of the mistrial in criminal cases (the speedy-trial clock typically resets under statutes modeled on the federal Speedy Trial Act), but practice varies widely and continuances are common. Civil cases move more slowly; a mistrial in a 12-month civil case can push resolution past the two-year mark.
There's a hidden cost in witness attrition. Witnesses who've testified once often resist a second appearance, especially if they feared retaliation or moved away. Prosecutors who lose a witness to attrition after a mistrial sometimes face the choice of a weaker retrial or a plea bargain they'd previously rejected.
Worked example: Suppose a burglary trial with eight prosecution witnesses and a defense expert runs five court days. Assume a public defender costs the county roughly $1,000 per trial day and the prosecutor's time similarly. The five-day trial costs about $10,000 in attorney time before jury costs and court staff. A retrial adds roughly the same amount plus new preparation, and the second trial may require re-deposing two witnesses at perhaps $500 each — so the retrial's marginal cost lands near $12,000 to $15,000 in staff time alone, a figure court budget offices typically report as a range rather than a single line item. That's before the intangible cost of delayed justice for everyone involved.
Civil vs. Criminal Mistrials: Different Rules, Different Stakes
The broad mechanism is identical, but the consequences diverge sharply. In a criminal case, the Double Jeopardy Clause — U.S. Constitution Amendment V, applied to states through the Fourteenth Amendment — bars retrial after an acquittal and after a mistrial granted over the defendant's objection absent manifest necessity. In a civil case, the Seventh Amendment doesn't create the same auto-bar; the question is whether the mistrial was caused by a defect that a new trial could cure.
In civil cases, mistrials most often arise from juror misconduct, a party's improper conduct, or a discovery violation. A civil mistrial usually means the case restarts, sometimes with a new complaint if the statute of limitations hasn't run, sometimes with a "hung jury" report that leads to a settlement conversation. Courts in some states apply a different standard for repeated hung juries — a second deadlock may push a plaintiff to dismiss or settle rather than face a third attempt.
The proportionality of mistrials differs too. A high-profile murder trial that ends in a mistrial after three months might have consumed more public resources than an entire year of misdemeanor trials. The stakes justify the scrutiny. Conversely, a small-claims case rarely goes to a mistrial at all, because many small-claims courts don't use juries and the judge simply rules.
One region-specific wrinkle: in several southern states and in federal military courts, procedural rules on the Allen charge and juror substitution differ from the civil rules. Defense counsel must know the local rule before asking for a mistrial on a hung-jury basis, because the judge may substitute an alternate and require the jury to continue deliberating instead.
Ten Things That Do Not Cause a Mistrial
The most common misconceptions come from television, where a dramatic objection seems to halt everything. In real practice, most errors are handled by an instruction to the jury, a brief recess, or a note for the record and appeal.
1: A sustained objection does not cause a mistrial. The judge says "sustained," instructs the jury to disregard, and the trial continues. 2: A prosecution witness giving an unresponsive answer rarely triggers a mistrial unless the answer reveals excluded evidence so damaging no instruction can cure it. 3: Juror disagreement during deliberations is not itself a mistrial — the judge waits for a deadlock, then applies the Allen charge test. 4: A juror sneezing or being late doesn't qualify. Real prejudice to the verdict must exist. 5: Mere procedural error — a late filing, a discovery misstep the judge can cure — is the usual subject of a motion in limine or a continuance, not a mistrial. 6: A judge's improper comment may draw a mistrial motion, but often appellate review happens only after verdict. 7: A prosecution's victory after closing argument isn't a mistrial trigger; errors in closing are handled by curative instruction or post-verdict appeal. 8: A juror who recognized a witness may be removed and replaced by an alternate without a mistrial if the replacement is clean. 9: A late-arriving witness is a scheduling problem, not legal prejudice. 10: One juror's holdout vote is normal deliberation. Only a declared deadlock after reasonable effort becomes a mistrial option.
The pattern is clear: mistrial is reserved for problems that the judge cannot fix with a curative instruction or a substitution. The remedy must be proportional to the harm, and that proportionality requirement is the thread running through every doctrine on this subject.
FAQ
Does a mistrial mean the charges are dropped?
No. A mistrial erases the proceeding but does not, by itself, dismiss charges. The prosecution typically decides whether to retry, and for hung juries and most federal mistrials the default is retrial. Charges are permanently dropped only when double jeopardy attaches — an acquittal, or a mistrial caused by bad-faith prosecutorial misconduct under Oregon v. Kennedy. A defendant should ask defense counsel to confirm whether jeopardy attached before treating the mistrial as a victory.
What happens to the jury after a mistrial?
The jury is typically discharged with the judge's thanks, and the jurors are instructed not to discuss the case publicly to protect the parties and preserve the possibility of retrial. In some jurisdictions, the judge can also admonish the jury about contacting witnesses or investigating after discharge. Jurors may be questioned afterward about misconduct in limited circumstances, but Rule 606(b)-style protections usually bar inquiries into deliberations themselves.
Can a mistrial be appealed?
Generally, a mistrial order is not itself a final appealable judgment, because the case is not over. Appeals happen after a retrial ends in a verdict, and at that point the defendant can argue that the double jeopardy bar should have presumptively attached. A small category of mistrial rulings — particularly those involving pretrial matters and some civil contempt rulings — can be reviewed earlier through mandamus or interlocutory appeal, but these are exceptions.
Does a mistrial cost the defendant more money?
Usually, yes in civil cases and only partly in criminal cases. In civil litigation, the defendant's own legal fees for the retrial add up because trial preparation is largely repeated, and a mistrial doesn't reset the total bill. In criminal cases, if the defendant is indigent, the public defender is paid by the state regardless, so the marginal cost to the defendant is mostly time and stress rather than cash.
What's the difference between a mistrial and a new trial?
A mistrial happens before a verdict, usually during the proceeding itself, and wipes out the trial in progress. A new trial is a post-verdict remedy where a judge sets aside a jury's verdict and orders a fresh trial. The legal triggers overlap (jury misconduct, improper evidence), but the timing and procedural posture differ sharply, and a new trial motion is governed by specific civil and criminal rules of procedure.
How long does it take to get a retrial after a mistrial?
Federal and many state statutes set a retrial within roughly 70 days after the mistrial order, traced to speedy-trial rules modeled on the federal Speedy Trial Act. In practice, margins of two to six months are common, and uncontested continuances can stretch the timeline further. Civil retrials vary widely and sometimes resolve through settlement before a second trial begins.
Can a judge declare a mistrial without either side asking?
Yes. A judge has authority to declare a mistrial sua sponte — on the court's own motion — when manifest necessity requires it, such as a hung jury or a juror's illness. The judge must still create a record, hear from counsel if possible, and find that less drastic remedies won't work. Unilateral mistrials get closer appellate scrutiny because the judge, not the parties, chose the remedy.
What if the mistrial was caused by the defendant's own conduct?
A defendant who deliberately provokes a mistrial to avoid an expected conviction is treated differently. The Kennedy standard was designed for prosecution overreach, but courts have confronted defendants who manufacture a mistrial to avoid a guilty verdict, and in some instances the government can seek retrial because the defendant can't benefit from jeopardy created by their own misconduct. Sanctions against counsel remain separate.
This article is general educational information about how mistrials function in U.S. courts and is not legal advice or a legal opinion on any case. Procedure varies by jurisdiction and by whether the matter is civil or criminal, and outcomes depend on the specific record a judge builds. Consult a licensed attorney in your state or federal district for advice on a specific trial, mistrial ruling, or appeal deadline. If a mistrial order has just been entered, note that deadlines for objecting, requesting findings, or filing post-order motions can be short and are often counted in days rather than weeks. In an emergency involving immediate danger to yourself or someone else, contact local emergency services or a crisis line rather than relying on any legal document.