Susan B. Anthony and the women she organized with saw a single core problem: American law treated women as civil non-persons in the voting booth, and every other inequality flowed from that exclusion. They responded by building a national movement, publishing a newspaper, petitioning Congress, and voting illegally on purpose to force a court test. The change they wanted was a constitutional amendment guaranteeing women the vote β a goal Anthony died 14 years before reaching, in 1906, when the 19th Amendment was still 14 years away.
The Legal Problem Anthony Diagnosed: Coverture and the Word "Male"
The specific grievance Anthony named most often was constitutional, not social. State constitutions had inserted the word "male" into their voting clauses, and the Fourteenth Amendment's second section had done the same at the federal level in 1868, penalizing any state that denied the franchise to "male inhabitants." That phrasing handed suffragists their evidence: Congress had written sex discrimination into the Constitution itself.
Behind that was the older doctrine of coverture, imported from English common law, under which a married woman's legal identity merged into her husband's. A wife could not sign a contract, keep her wages, or sue in her own name in most states. When Anthony campaigned against the vote restriction, she was attacking the keystone: without the ballot, women had no mechanism to change the property laws, divorce statutes, or wage rules that coverture imposed.
Anthony's own history shaped the diagnosis. She was raised a Quaker, where women spoke in meeting and were educated alongside men, and she worked as a teacher and later as a temperance organizer. In the temperance movement she watched women raise money and gather signatures while male leaders controlled the agenda. That experience convinced her, as she put it in her speeches, that no reform would stick until women could elect the men who wrote the laws.
The problem had an economic edge that later summaries tend to soften. Anthony served as an agent for the American Anti-Slavery Society in the 1850s and traveled constantly, which brought her into contact with married women whose husbands could claim their earnings. A working wife in New York could watch her wages pass to a husband by law. Voting was the lever, but the harm was rent, wages, and custody.
Building an Organization When No National Body Existed
In 1851 Anthony met Elizabeth Cady Stanton, and the partnership became the engine of the movement for the next half century. Anthony handled travel, logistics, and money; Stanton wrote the speeches and manifestos. Stanton had organized the 1848 Seneca Falls convention with Lucretia Mott, where the Declaration of Sentiments listed 18 grievances modeled on the Declaration of Independence. Anthony brought the organizational discipline that turned a convention into a campaign.
Their first sustained vehicle was the New York State Woman Suffrage Association, which Anthony helped build in 1869, the same year Wyoming Territory granted women full voting rights β the first place in the United States to do so. Anthony and Stanton then founded the National Woman Suffrage Association that year, opposing ratification of the Fifteenth Amendment because it enfranchised Black men while excluding women. That stance split the movement; Lucy Stone's American Woman Suffrage Association backed the amendment and accepted a state-by-state strategy. The two wings stayed apart for 21 years.
The record of what Anthony actually did is concrete. She served as president of the National American Woman Suffrage Association from 1892 to 1900, after the two organizations merged in 1890. She delivered an estimated 75 to 100 speeches a year in her peak years and traveled by train across the Plains and the West, often staying in temperance hotels and farmhouses. She also raised the money to keep the operation solvent, including a $50,000 life insurance policy she assigned to the cause.
Her most durable institutional act was the four-volume History of Woman Suffrage, which she began with Stanton and Matilda Joslyn Gage in 1881. The volumes collected convention minutes, legislative records, and correspondence that would otherwise have been lost. Writers who rely on that record owe a debt to the organizers who compiled it β and historians note the volumes are selective, favoring the Stanton-Anthony wing's version of disputes.
The Newspaper That Kept the Message Consistent for 17 Years
On January 8, 1868, Anthony and Stanton launched The Revolution in New York City, a weekly paper with the motto "Men, their rights and nothing more; women, their rights and nothing less." The paper covered suffrage, equal pay, divorce law, and the eight-hour workday, and it ran for roughly two and a half years before debt forced its sale in 1870. Anthony personally carried about $10,000 of the publication's debt for years afterward, a figure she repaid from lecture fees.
The paper mattered less for its circulation than for its message discipline. Anthony understood that a movement spread across thousands of miles needed a single, repeatable argument. The Revolution supplied the talking points: women pay taxes without representation, women obey laws they cannot influence, and the Constitution's own language contradicts the exclusion. Those lines appeared in local suffrage speeches for decades.
Anthony then contributed to a second publication, the National Citizen and Ballot Box, edited by Matilda Joslyn Gage from 1878, and later the Woman's Tribune. The pattern was the same: keep a printed record, give local organizers a shared vocabulary, and document every legislative hearing so the next campaign could cite it.
The business side is instructive and rarely told. Suffrage publishing ran on subscriptions that arrived slowly and printing bills that did not. Anthony's willingness to accept personal debt for the paper shows how thin the movement's margins were β and why Anthony spent so much of her later career raising money rather than writing.
The Illegal Vote of 1872 and the Court Case That Followed
On November 5, 1872, Anthony registered and voted in the presidential election in Rochester, New York, with 14 other women, after persuading election inspectors to acceptε₯Ήδ»¬η registrations. She was arrested on November 18 and charged with voting illegally, a federal offense. Her trial, held in Canandaigua, New York, in June 1873, became the movement's most public spectacle.
The trial was rigged in a way that deserves precision. The presiding judge, Supreme Court Associate Justice Ward Hunt, ruled before the jury could deliberate β reading a written opinion holding that women had no constitutional right to vote β and directed a guilty verdict. Anthony's lawyer objected; Hunt overruled and fined her $100 plus the costs of prosecution. Anthony announced she would never pay, and the court, apparently fearing an appeal to a higher court, declined to imprison her, which foreclosed her appeal.
Anthony used the verdict as a platform. She delivered her "Is It a Crime for a Citizen of the United States to Vote?" speech across upstate New York in 1873, arguing that the Fourteenth Amendment's privileges-or-immunities clause already gave women citizenship rights, including the franchise. The speech was printed and distributed by the thousands.
Her legal theory lost. In Minor v. Happersett (1875), the Supreme Court ruled unanimously that citizenship did not carry a right to vote and that states could exclude women from the polls. Anthony's reading of the Fourteenth Amendment was rejected, and the loss redirected the movement toward a constitutional amendment β the only path the Court left open.
The Amendment Campaign: Petitioning, Lobbying, and the Long Wait
Anthony's post-1875 strategy was a federal amendment, and she pursued it with the patience of someone who expected to lose for decades. She drafted the text that became the Anthony Amendment: "The right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of sex." It was introduced in Congress in 1878 by Senator Aaron A. Sargent of California and reintroduced every session for 41 years.
She testified before congressional committees repeatedly, including a Senate hearing in 1884 and a House hearing in 1892. She collected petitions β one campaign gathered roughly 10,000 signatures in a single year β and delivered them to Congress, knowing each one would be filed and ignored. The point was to build a record that a future Congress could not dismiss.
The petition strategy had a measurable civic purpose beyond symbolism. Each signature list was a census of sympathetic voters and a recruiting tool, and the delivery ceremonies drew press coverage. Anthony also maintained a working relationship with sympathetic congressmen who could reintroduce the amendment and keep it alive procedurally.
She never saw the amendment pass. When she died on March 13, 1906, in Rochester at 86, the measure had not reached a floor vote. Congress approved the 19th Amendment on June 4, 1919, and the required 36 states ratified it by August 18, 1920. Anthony's 14-year gap between death and ratification is the number that best captures the movement's timeline.
State-by-State Wins Anthony Built the Foundation For
The federal amendment stalled, but Anthony's organization kept the pressure on state legislatures, and those wins built the political credibility that eventually moved Congress. The tally matters: Wyoming enfranchised women in 1869, Utah in 1870, Colorado in 1893, Idaho in 1896, Washington in 1910, California in 1911, and New York in 1917. By 1919, 15 states had granted full suffrage and several more allowed presidential voting.
Anthony personally campaigned in several of those fights. She worked the Kansas campaign of 1867, which lost, and the Colorado campaign of 1877, which also lost β a reminder that most of her state campaigns failed. The successful western states gave suffragists a foothold because territorial and frontier legislatures were less bound by eastern property-law traditions and wanted to attract women settlers.
The state wins also produced the votes. When the 19th Amendment came before Congress, the senators and representatives who supported it came disproportionately from suffrage states, where women were already voters and politicians had learned to court them. Anthony's state-level groundwork, much of it conducted through NAWSA's local auxiliaries, supplied that map.
The organizational cost was heavy. NAWSA under Anthony and her successor Carrie Chapman Catt fought over strategy β Catt favored a state-by-state "winning plan" while younger activists like Alice Paul pushed for a federal amendment with confrontational tactics. Paul split off in 1913 to form the Congressional Union, later the National Woman's Party. Anthony's legacy sits in both branches: the patient institutional route she built and the confrontational one that finally forced the issue.
What Anthony Did Not Solve β and the Limit of Her Record
Anthony's movement had blind spots that modern readers should see plainly. She and Stanton opposed the Fifteenth Amendment in 1869, arguing that educated white women deserved the vote before Black men, and some of their rhetoric from that period used racist language. The split with Frederick Douglass, a longtime ally, was real and painful. Anthony's record on race is mixed at best, and treating her as a pure hero requires ignoring that record.
The movement's second limit was class and region. Suffrage organizations were run largely by white, middle-class, educated women, and their campaigns in the South often accommodated white supremacists by arguing that white women's votes would offset Black men's. The 19th Amendment's ratification depended on southern states, and its passage did not enfranchise Black women in practice across the Jim Crow South, where poll taxes, literacy tests, and violence kept them from the ballot until the Voting Rights Act of 1965.
A third limit was structural. Anthony's amendment said nothing about other barriers to voting. It removed sex as a disqualification and left poll taxes, residency rules, and registration schemes intact. The practical right to vote for poor women, Black women, and Native American women remained contingent on state law for another 45 years.
None of that erases what Anthony built. A movement with no national staff, no reliable funding, and no legal victories in its first two decades nonetheless produced the constitutional text, the organizational network, and the public argument that outlasted its founder by nearly half a century.
A Comparison: Anthony's Strategy Versus the Militant Wing
The suffrage movement's two main strategies are often blurred together. Here is how they differed on the dimensions that decided the outcome.
| Dimension | Anthony / NAWSA route | Paul / National Woman's Party |
|---|---|---|
| Core tactic | Petitions, lobbying, state referenda | Picketing, marches, hunger strikes |
| Target | State legislatures, then Congress | President and Congress directly |
| Amendment text | Anthony Amendment, introduced 1878 | Same text, new pressure campaign |
| Key years | 1869β1900 under Anthony; 1900β1920 under Catt | 1913β1920 |
| Funding model | Membership dues, wealthy donors, lecture fees | Wealthy patrons and fundraising events |
| Trade-off | Slow, incremental, built durable state organizations | Fast public attention, alienated some politicians |
| Result | 15 suffrage states by 1919 | Forced Wilson's 1918 endorsement |
The two wings needed each other. NAWSA's state organizations provided the ratification votes; the Woman's Party's protests made the issue impossible to ignore. Anthony's institutional design and Paul's confrontational pressure were complementary, not rival, tactics, and the historical record supports treating them as two halves of one campaign.
How to Use This History: Three Practical Checks
Anyone researching Anthony for a school paper, a museum exhibit, or a civic argument can apply three checks to separate documented fact from legend.
1: Check the primary source in the History of Woman Suffrage before quoting a speech. The volumes are on archive.org and contain the convention minutes and legislative hearings. Note which wing of the movement compiled each volume, because the account of the 1869 split is told from the Stanton-Anthony side. 2: Verify the 1872 trial record against Minor v. Happersett (1875). The Supreme Court decision is short and public, and it states plainly that the Constitution does not confer the vote on women. That ruling, not the Canandaigua verdict, is the legal turning point. 3: Distinguish the amendment's introduction date (1878) from its passage (1919). A 41-year gap between introduction and congressional approval is the honest timeline, and it explains why Anthony's death in 1906 is not a footnote. Anthony herself is the author of the amendment text, not its ratifier.
If a source says Anthony "won" the vote or "secured" the amendment, it is compressing a campaign she did not live to see finish. The accurate sentence is that she wrote the amendment, organized for it for 37 years, and died 14 years before ratification.
FAQ
Did Susan B. Anthony actually vote illegally?
Yes, on November 5, 1872, in Rochester, New York, along with 14 other women, after persuading election inspectors to register them. She was arrested on November 18 and tried in Canandaigua in June 1873 before Justice Ward Hunt, who directed a guilty verdict and fined her $100 plus costs. She refused to pay, and the court did not imprison her, which prevented her from appealing.
What was the exact text of the amendment Anthony drafted?
The text reads: "The right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of sex." Senator Aaron A. Sargent introduced it in 1878, and it was reintroduced in every congressional session until Congress approved it on June 4, 1919 β a 41-year gap. The wording survived unchanged into the 19th Amendment.
Was Anthony's movement united?
No. The 1869 split over the Fifteenth Amendment created two organizations: Anthony and Stanton's National Woman Suffrage Association, which opposed the amendment because it excluded women, and Lucy Stone's American Woman Suffrage Association, which supported it and pursued state campaigns. The two merged in 1890 as the National American Woman Suffrage Association, with Anthony as a vice president and later president from 1892 to 1900.
How long after Anthony's death was the amendment ratified?
Fourteen years. Anthony died on March 13, 1906, in Rochester at age 86; Congress approved the amendment in June 1919 and the 36th state ratified it on August 18, 1920. She had led the amendment campaign for 28 years after its 1878 introduction and never saw a floor vote in either chamber.
Did the 19th Amendment give all women the vote in practice?
No. The amendment removed sex as a legal barrier, but Black women in the Jim Crow South faced poll taxes, literacy tests, and violence that kept them from the ballot until the Voting Rights Act of 1965. Native American women were largely excluded until the Snyder Act of 1924 and later state actions. Anthony's amendment addressed one disqualification, not all of them.
What did Anthony do for a living while organizing?
She worked as a teacher in New York from the late 1830s into the 1840s and later as an agent for the American Anti-Slavery Society, then supported herself largely through lecture fees and book sales. She assigned a $50,000 life insurance policy to the suffrage cause and carried about $10,000 of debt from The Revolution for years after the paper folded in 1870.
Why did Anthony's Supreme Court strategy fail?
Her argument was that the Fourteenth Amendment's privileges-or-immunities clause made women citizens with voting rights. In Minor v. Happersett (1875), a unanimous Supreme Court held that citizenship does not automatically confer the franchise and that states may exclude women from voting. The loss convinced the movement that only a constitutional amendment could settle the question.
How did Anthony's approach differ from Alice Paul's?
Anthony built a membership organization that lobbied Congress, petitioned, and won state referenda, while Paul's National Woman's Party used picketing, marches, and hunger strikes to pressure President Wilson directly. Anthony's route supplied the state ratification votes; Paul's supplied the public pressure. The 19th Amendment needed both, and historians treat the two wings as complementary rather than competing.