If you cannot or will not deliver rescue breaths, the best action is to switch to compression-only CPR: hard, fast chest compressions at 100 to 120 per minute, 5 to 6 cm deep, with full recoil and minimal interruption, and to keep going until help arrives or an AED is ready. The single exception is a drowning, suffocation, or child collapse, where five initial rescue breaths matter enough that you should call for a second rescuer who will give them. Everything below explains how to run that decision cleanly.

What Compression-Only CPR Actually Is and What It Is Not

Compression-only CPR means continuous chest compressions with no mouth-to-mouth ventilation at all. The American Heart Association and the European Resuscitation Council both recognize it as an acceptable adult out-of-hospital approach for untrained or unwilling bystanders, which is not the same as saying it is equal to full CPR in every case. It is not "hands-only" in the sense of being gentle; depth and rate standards are identical to conventional CPR.

The distinction that matters is who the casualty is. For a witnessed adult cardiac arrest, the blood is still oxygenated at the moment of collapse, so circulating it with compressions buys meaningful time. For a drowning victim or a child who went down from a breathing problem, the blood is already deoxygenated, and compressions alone circulate oxygen-poor blood. That is the mechanical reason the two situations split into different recommendations.

What it is not: it is not a legal shield, it is not a substitute for calling emergency services, and it is not permission to stop early. The moment you begin, your job is to continue until professional responders take over, an AED delivers a shock and instructs you to resume, or you are physically unable to continue.

A practical framing helps. You are not choosing between "good CPR" and "bad CPR." You are choosing between some circulation and none, and none is fatal within minutes. The European Resuscitation Council's 2021 guidelines put the survival window for an untreated out-of-hospital cardiac arrest in the range of minutes, not hours, which is why any compression is better than standing still.

The Exact Numbers to Hit: Rate, Depth, Recoil, and Interruption Limits

Aim for 100 to 120 compressions per minute, which is roughly two per second, or the tempo of "Stayin' Alive." Push at least 5 cm and no more than 6 cm deep in an average adult, which is about one-third of chest depth. Allow the chest to come all the way back up between compressions, because a chest that never recoils keeps pressure inside and chokes off the filling that makes the next push useful.

Keep interruptions under 10 seconds. That figure comes from the AHA's emphasis on minimizing pauses, and it is the number that separates competent compression-only CPR from panicked compression-only CPR. Checking for a pulse for 30 seconds, hunting for a phone, or repositioning repeatedly all count against you.

Parameter Target Common bystander error
Rate 100–120 per minute Racing past 140 in adrenaline
Depth (adult) 5–6 cm Pushing under 4 cm out of fear of hurting ribs
Recoil Full, every compression Leaning on the chest between pushes
Pause limit Under 10 seconds Long pulse checks or phone fumbling
Hand position Lower half of sternum, heel of one hand, second hand on top Compressing the ribs or upper stomach

If you have a metronome app or a phone that can play a song at 100 to 120 beats per minute, use it. Bystanders consistently drift faster than they think under stress, and a rate of 140 reduces how much the heart refills between beats.

One number worth internalizing: at 100 per minute with no interruptions, you deliver 100 compressions in a minute. Lose 20 seconds to a phone call and repositioning and you drop to roughly 66. That arithmetic, not technique, is where most bystander CPR quietly fails.

Why Compression-Only Works for Adults but Not for Drowning or Children

The strongest case for compression-only CPR is a sudden adult collapse, especially one you watched happen. In that scenario the AHA's position is that hands-only CPR performs comparably to conventional CPR for out-of-hospital adult cardiac arrest, and it removes the two things bystanders most often refuse to do: mouth-to-mouth and the fear of doing it wrong.

The case against it is pediatric and asphyxial arrest. Children rarely go into cardiac arrest from a primary heart rhythm problem; they go down because breathing failed first, from choking, drowning, asthma, or infection. The AHA's pediatric guidance is explicit that rescue breaths are part of the standard for children, and its "five cycles of 30 compressions to 2 breaths" structure exists because ventilation is doing real work there.

Drowning follows the same logic. A submerged person has no oxygen in the blood, so compressions alone move a shipment of nothing. The AHA and the International Liaison Committee on Resuscitation both recommend starting with rescue breaths in drowning, which is precisely the situation where an unwilling rescuer should recruit someone else rather than default to silent compressions.

If you find yourself alone with a drowned child and cannot give breaths, the honest answer is compression-only CPR plus an immediate, loud call for a second rescuer. The 2021 ERC guidelines describe this as a compromise, not an equivalent, and the compromise is still worth making while help travels.

The Rescue-Breath Alternative That Requires No Mouth Contact

Several barriers stop people from giving breaths, including fear of infection, squeamishness, and the awkwardness of mouth-to-mouth with a stranger. There is a cleaner option when you have a barrier device: a pocket mask or a face shield with a one-way valve lets you ventilate without direct lip contact.

A pocket mask changes the risk conversation, though not the skill requirement. A seal has to be formed and the head has to be tilted correctly, and a mask that leaks delivers nothing but a hiss. If you carry a keyring face shield, read the instructions on the packet before you need it, because the valve orientation matters and the plastic is unforgiving under pressure.

Bag-valve-mask ventilation is a step beyond that, requiring two hands, a second rescuer for a proper seal in most cases, and training to avoid overinflating the stomach. A single untrained rescuer with a BVM often delivers less air than a well-sealed pocket mask.

The judgment that matters: if a barrier device is within arm's reach and you are willing to use it, use it, because full CPR with a mask outperforms compression-only CPR in a child or drowning victim. If it is not there, do not go hunting through a house for one while a heart is stopped.

What to Do When an AED Arrives Mid-Compression

An AED does not replace compressions; it interrupts them briefly, and how you handle that interruption is where outcomes are won. The AHA's sequence is to attach the pads, let the device analyze, deliver a shock if advised, and resume compressions immediately, without pausing to check for a pulse unless the AED prompts it.

Minimize the hands-off time. The pads go on a bare, dry chest, with any medication patch removed and any water wiped away, because a wet chest can arc current across the skin instead of through the heart. The AED's voice prompts are the authority; when it says "do not touch the patient," your hands come off, and when it says "resume compressions," you start on the next syllable.

Keep your compression-only rhythm going while the second rescuer applies pads, if you have one. If you are alone, stop compressions for as long as it takes to attach the pads and follow prompts, because the shock, if indicated, is the only thing that can restart a heart that has a shockable rhythm.

An AED is designed for untrained laypeople and will not fire unless a shockable rhythm is present, which is why the advice to use one overrides most hesitation. If the device says "no shock advised," resume compressions at once and do not assume the person is safe to leave.

Hands-Only CPR Step by Step, Including What to Do When Your Body Gives Out

Here is the sequence, in order, for an adult collapse where you are not giving breaths.

1: Confirm the scene is safe and check for response by tapping the shoulders and shouting. If unresponsive and not breathing normally, the arrest is presumed. 2: Call emergency services on speakerphone and put the phone down beside you, so the dispatcher can coach you while you work. 3: Position your hands on the lower half of the sternum, heel of one hand down, the other on top, fingers interlocked, arms straight, shoulders over your hands. 4: Begin compressions at 100 to 120 per minute, 5 to 6 cm deep, full recoil each time, and do not stop to reassess. 5: Send someone for an AED if another person is present, and keep compressing until it is attached and analyzing. 6: Swap with another trained rescuer every 2 minutes, or sooner if you tire, because fatigue degrades depth before it degrades rate.

Failure handling matters as much as the steps. If a rib gives way under your hands, keep going; rib and sternal fractures are a recognized consequence of correct-depth compressions, and stopping to inspect the chest is worse than the fracture. If you vomit or blood appears, turn the head to the side briefly if you must and resume immediately. If your arms give out entirely, hand off to anyone willing and coach them aloud rather than stopping altogether.

The dispatcher is an underused resource. Emergency medical dispatchers in many systems are trained to talk untrained callers through compression-only CPR, and following their voice beats improvising. Say clearly, "I cannot give breaths," so the dispatcher stops prompting you for them.

Common Mistakes That Quietly Reduce the Value of Compression-Only CPR

The most frequent mistake is depth failure under emotional load. Bystanders who are frightened of causing harm push 3 to 4 cm, and shallow compressions barely move blood. The AHA's depth floor of 5 cm exists because the difference is measurable.

The second is leaning. Between compressions, people rest their body weight on their hands, so the chest never fully recoils, and the heart never refills. Lift your hands just enough to let the chest rise, without losing the position.

The third is stopping to look. Bystanders stop to check for a pulse, watch the face, or wait for a sign of life, and each pause resets the clock. In compression-only CPR you keep going and let the AED and the arriving crew do the assessment.

The fourth is the wrong target. Hands placed too high, too low, or on the ribs deliver less efficient compression and more injury. The lower half of the sternum is the landmark, not the "middle of the chest" as a rough guess.

Finally, the wrong-patient error. Compression-only CPR is right for an adult who collapsed suddenly and wrong as a default for a child or drowning victim. Switching to it because breaths are unpleasant is a distinct decision from switching to it because you are unable, and only the second is being recommended here.

When You Should Still Stop and Give Breaths, and Who Should Take Over

There is a short list of circumstances where you should override the compression-only default: a child or infant, a drowning or suffocation arrest, and any collapse where you know breathing stopped first. In each case, the right move is to find a rescuer who will give breaths, and to call for one loudly and specifically rather than generally.

Ask a named person. "You, in the blue jacket, call 911 and come back" outperforms "someone call an ambulance," because diffusion of responsibility is real and named instructions cut through it. The AHA's guidance on bystander recruitment is built on this exact observation.

If no second rescuer comes and you remain unwilling, continue compressions and accept that the outcome is less favorable in the asphyxial cases. That is a regret-minimizing choice rather than an optimal one, and it is still better than nothing. If you are unwilling but have a mask, use it; willingness with a barrier is a different question from willingness without one.

If a trained responder arrives, hand over immediately with a clear report: when the collapse happened, how long you have been compressing, whether an AED was applied, and whether a shock was delivered. That handover is worth 30 seconds of compressions.

How Good Samaritan Laws Treat Unwilling Rescuers

Good Samaritan protections vary by jurisdiction, and a rescuer who gives compression-only CPR is generally covered in the United States and across much of Europe, though the wording differs. In the US, most state statutes protect lay rescuers who act in good faith without expectation of compensation, and some states additionally require the rescuer to have called 911 or to have acted without gross negligence.

The important boundary: these laws protect you from liability for ordinary mistakes, not for abandoning a person once you have started, and not for reckless conduct. They also do not compel you to start at all. Most statutes are about immunity for the willing rescuer, not about a duty to rescue.

Jurisdiction matters. The specifics of consent, immunity, and what counts as "emergency care" are set by state or national law, so a reader in Australia, the UK, or Canada should check their local statute rather than assume the US framing applies. This is general educational information, not legal advice.

The practical takeaway for an unwilling rescuer is not a legal one. It is that compression-only CPR is a recognized, defensible middle path that keeps you out of the hardest question and keeps the casualty's circulation going while someone else arrives.

FAQ

Can compression-only CPR restart a heart on its own?

Rarely, and that is not its purpose. It buys time by circulating blood until an AED or advanced care can address the rhythm. Early defibrillation is the intervention that converts a shockable rhythm, which is why summoning an AED matters as much as starting compressions.

Is it illegal to skip the breaths?

In most jurisdictions, no, and Good Samaritan statutes typically protect a lay rescuer acting in good faith. The more useful boundary is that you should not stop compressions once you have begun, because abandonment and gross negligence sit outside the usual immunity.

What rate and depth do dispatchers coach untrained callers toward?

Dispatchers in systems with telephone CPR protocols coach callers to push hard and fast, roughly 100 to 120 per minute, without a ventilations component, and to keep going until responders arrive. Follow the dispatcher's voice over your own estimate, since they can hear the pace in your counting.

Does compression-only CPR work the same on a child?

No. For children, the AHA's standard includes rescue breaths, because pediatric arrest usually starts with a breathing failure. If you cannot give breaths, compress anyway, but make finding a rescuer who will ventilate your priority rather than a hopeful extra.

What if the person starts breathing during compressions?

That is the point at which you stop, place them in the recovery position if they are breathing normally and unresponsive, and monitor until help arrives. Do not sit them upright or give them food or drink, and keep the AED attached.

How long should I keep going alone?

Until professional responders take over, an AED directs otherwise, or you are physically unable to continue. Fatigue degrades compression depth before it degrades speed, so a handover to a fresh rescuer every 2 minutes is worth arranging early, before you fade.

Does a face shield count as giving breaths?

Yes, a face shield or pocket mask with a one-way valve lets you ventilate without direct contact, and that turns an unwilling rescuer into a full-CPR rescuer for a child or drowning victim. Practice the seal once at home, because a leaking mask delivers nothing useful.

Is there a situation where I should not do compression-only CPR at all?

If the person is responsive, breathing normally, or has an obvious injury that makes chest compressions unsafe to attempt, do not start. If you are unsure, call emergency services and let the dispatcher decide with you, and remember the article's scope is adult collapse where arrest is presumed.

This article is general educational information about bystander CPR and is not a diagnosis, a treatment plan, or legal advice. Compression-only CPR is a recognized compromise, not a guarantee of any outcome, and the specifics of good Samaritan protection are set by your local jurisdiction. For immediate danger, a suspected cardiac arrest, or a risk of self-harm, contact your local emergency or crisis services without delay.